PNC TotalRewards - The Award-Winning Banking Loyalty Program With 1M+ Users

Project Overview:
The PNC TotalRewards program was conceived to foster stronger connections with our valued customers. We aimed to create an engaging and rewarding experience that encouraged deeper banking relationships. This case study outlines our journey from understanding customer needs to launching a highly successful loyalty initiative that exceeded all expectations.

Role:
Product Designer

Tools:
Figma, FigJam, Photoshop, Jira, Confluence

Project Length:
2 years

Problem Statement

Our core challenge was to design a banking loyalty program that would effectively incentivize existing PNC customers to deepen their relationship with the bank. We identified a need to reward customers who demonstrated a significant commitment to PNC, fostering greater loyalty and engagement. The objective was to move beyond transactional relationships to build more meaningful partnerships with our customers.

Target Audience

The primary target audience for PNC TotalRewards was the mass affluent segment. Specifically, we focused on customers who held at least $25,000 in their accounts with us. We also aimed to attract individuals who had the potential to consolidate their banking relationships with PNC, bringing their balances to or above the $25,000 threshold. This segment represented a key opportunity to increase customer lifetime value and deepen our market penetration.

Design Process

Research

Our design process was iterative and user-centric, ensuring that the final product would resonate with our target audience. It began with extensive user and market research, involving existing customers and employing testing prototypes in collaboration with our dedicated research team. This initial phase provided invaluable insights into customer needs and preferences.

Ideation

Following this, we moved into an ideation phase, starting with low-fidelity wireframes to quickly explore various concepts. The next step involved creating high-fidelity prototypes, a process that required close collaboration with product managers, business analysts, content designers, and the legal team to ensure all aspects of the program were thoroughly considered and compliant. 

Prototype & Test

Finally, we conducted rigorous testing with real bank customers, potential users of TotalRewards, to validate our design decisions and refine the user experience, making the value proposition clear and the sign-up process both enticing and user-friendly.

Metrics for Success

The primary metric used to define and measure the success of the PNC TotalRewards program was user sign-ups. Our ambitious target was to achieve over 1 million enrollments within the first nine months of its release. This quantifiable goal allowed us to track the program's adoption rate and its effectiveness in attracting our target audience.

Outcomes

The PNC TotalRewards program achieved remarkable success, surpassing our initial goals by a significant margin. We proudly achieved over 1 million enrollments within the very first month of its launch. Furthermore, the program was launched simultaneously on both desktop and mobile platforms, resulting in a high level of user satisfaction across all touch points. Adding to this success, PNC TotalRewards garnered multiple prestigious awards at the Loyalty360 Awards ceremony shortly after its release, underscoring the quality and impact of our design and strategy.

Challenges and Solutions

One of the most significant challenges we encountered was the extensive number of content iterations required due to stringent legal requirements. These back-and-forth exchanges were beginning to slow down our progress and put us at risk of missing our launch timeline. To address this, I took the initiative to establish standing office hours meetings. This dedicated time brought together representatives from the legal, product, content, and design teams. By regularly reviewing newly created designs and content weekly in a collaborative setting, we ensured that each group had a clear understanding of the project's direction and could provide timely feedback. This proactive approach kept everyone aligned and significantly streamlined the design process, allowing us to overcome the legal review bottleneck.

Learnings and Reflections

This project reinforced the critical importance of early and continuous cross-functional collaboration. The challenge with legal content iteration highlighted how proactive communication and dedicated forums for discussion can resolve complex issues swiftly. If I were to embark on a similar project again, I would push even earlier for the establishment of such collaborative sessions. Building a strong rapport and understanding between different departments from the outset is key to navigating complexities and ensuring a smooth, efficient design and development process. The success of TotalRewards also underscored the power of focusing on a clear value proposition that genuinely resonates with the target audience, making adoption feel like a natural and beneficial choice for the customer.

Conclusion

The PNC TotalRewards loyalty program stands as a testament to what can be achieved with a user-centered design approach, strong cross-functional teamwork, and a clear understanding of business objectives. Exceeding enrollment targets within the first month and receiving industry accolades are strong indicators of its success. The program not only deepened customer relationships but also provided a valuable framework for future customer engagement initiatives at PNC. The insights gained from this project will continue to inform our strategies for creating impactful and rewarding customer experiences.

Justin Fuss

LinkedIn

717-422-7250

Copyright © Justin Fuss 2026

justin@justinfuss.com